Case Studies

Maximising Recoveries and Cash Flow: The Power of a 1st Pass Audit Model

global-retailer-audit-partnership

Executive Summary

A major global retailer engaged Audit Partnership to assess whether our recovery audit model could outperform their long-standing provider in the U.S. market. Within a single audit cycle, our results led to a decisive change, and Audit Partnership was promoted from 2nd Pass to Primary Audit Provider (1st Pass). Through our excellent 1st pass approach, accelerated audit cycles, and a more profound commitment of resources, we delivered a 2.5x increase in recoveries, a 30% “in-year” cash flow realisation, and significantly enhanced buyer and supplier engagement. This case study outlines how we redefined audit’s strategic value within the retailer’s procure-to-pay ecosystem.

Objective

The client, a globally recognised retail leader, approached Audit Partnership with clear goals:

  • Reverse declining recovery trends in their U.S. operations
  • Accelerate audit cycles for earlier financial realisation
  • Minimise friction between finance, buyers, and suppliers
  • Introduce an excellent 1st-pass billing structure for greater accuracy, transparency, and efficiency

Organisation Background

For 15 years, the retailer had maintained the same audit provider and post-audit processes in their U.S. market. While consistent, the process became stagnant, marked by declining recoveries and increased friction with suppliers due to outdated claim cycles. Having partnered with the client since 2002 in the UK and since 2015 in other North American markets, Audit Partnership was invited to trial their differentiated methodology in the U.S., with the potential to redefine their global audit strategy.

Audit Partnership’s Service

Upon appointment, Audit Partnership immediately differentiated itself through both scale and strategy:

1. Resource Expansion

We more than doubled the audit resources compared to the incumbent, ensuring broader and deeper coverage without compromising speed. Our scalable model allowed this investment while remaining cost-effective and performance-driven.

2. Targeted Recovery Roadmap

We developed a phased claim rollout, prioritising high-impact categories that would deliver maximum immediate cash flow. This also allowed us to maintain audit precision while ramping up quickly.

3. Accelerated Half-Year Audits

Audit Partnership transitioned the client from traditional post-year-end audits to biannual audits, ensuring all activity was reviewed within tighter timeframes. This resulted in:

  • Earlier error detection
  • Timelier claim validation
  • More relevant feedback for stakeholders

4. Excellent 1st-Pass Billing Practice

A central pillar of success was the introduction of our proprietary, excellent 1st-pass billing methodology:

  • Our audit team reviewed promotional receivables raised by buyers for accuracy before they were sent to suppliers.
  • We raised our own claims using the same billing system as internal buyers, which enhanced transparency and built trust.
  • This alignment minimised audit friction, boosted acceptance rates, and gave suppliers real-time visibility.

5. Enhanced Reporting and Stakeholder Communication

Customised reporting frameworks were built for both operational teams and senior trading leadership. These reports:

  • Showed audit value by department
  • Identified recurring error patterns
  • Offered actionable insights for buyers and compliance teams

Highlights on Excellent 1st Pass Results

  • 2.5x Increase in Recoveries: Compared to previous audit cycles
  • 30% In-Year Cashflow Realisation: A material working capital improvement
  • Fewer Buyer Errors: Driven by pre-bill validation and audit alignment
  • Increased Audit Support: Buyers gained visibility, understood financial impact, and became audit advocates
  • Improved Supplier Relations: Timely, transparent claims strengthened trust
  • Proactive Error Prevention: Insights from  excellent 1st-pass claims enabled recommendations for system control enhancements

Conclusion

Audit Partnership’s excellent 1st-pass model, combined with accelerated review cycles and deep audit intelligence, not only improved recoveries but also strengthened cross-functional collaboration, improved supplier trust, and delivered real, in-year value. This isn’t just a story of increased recoveries; it’s a strategic shift in how audit can integrate into the wider procedure-to-pay process to drive smarter, faster, and more sustainable business outcomes.

Let’s get started